lurkerwithout: (Reading cat)

Token by Alisa Kwitney & Joelle Jones, with lettering by Steve Wands

Is still Sunday somewhere. In the secret hearts of all good children perhaps...

So this was a happy find. I'd thought it had gotten canceled when the minx line went down. Which would have been a shame as its a very nice story. Nothing too different, more "teen girl comes of age" that was typical of the line. Kwitney and Jones' take focuses on Shira Spektor a fifteen-year old Jewish girl growing up in Miami. She's being raised by her widowed lawyer father with the help of her grandmother and great-aunt. Shira's a very zaftig looking girl who is, of course, the outsider at her school. She's awkward and shy, trying to cope with her father starting to date his secretary and the fact that she's never even been kissed. Which is where ne'er do well Rafael Wilson enters the picture...

Like I said, its very standard teen drama. But very well crafted standard teen drama...
lurkerwithout: (Reading cat)

The New York Four written by Brian Wood, art by Ryan Kelly
Emiko Superstar written by Mariko Tamaki, art by Steve Rolston

As many of you likely already know, DC recently announced they were ending their minx line of books. Lots of armchair analysis as to why. Poor marketing, not producing a consistent product, etc etc. I still have no real idea if the line had much appeal to its target audience, but I know I liked the majority of it. And two of what look to be the last output were Brian Wood's The New York Four and Emiko Superstar from Mariko Tamaki...

The first follows four female college freshman at a New York school. Wood excells when it comes to writing about people in New York, no matter what the rest of the setting looks like. With the only real criticism of the book being that it is very much the start of a series. The ending is weaker than it could be. Which, now that Wood will have to shop the series around for a new publisher, is kind of annoying...

Tamaki's book is in some ways a normal teen-age coming of age story. Her lead has to discover her own self-worth, realize who is and isn't worth listening to and balancing responsibility with staying true to self. But while the basic underlying story isn't anything new, Tamaki crafts it well, using a background of an indy/underground performance art scene. Emiko Superstar makes a high point for minx to go out on...
lurkerwithout: (Who's next)
So there's been A LOT of discussion on DC's decision to cancel their minx line of comics. And one of the things I'm seeing is that the stories were too Afterschool Special and not enough Fantasy. Now I enjoyed a good portion of the line, but then despite enjoying a good Gilmore Girls rerun I'm not a 13 year old girl...

But many of you out there used to be. So speak up, would a line of comics that were basically All-Ages Vertigo have appealed to you? Actually Books of Magic, despite being a Vertigo book, was pretty much along those lines. So LJ-lady friends, when you were in that tweener age range, is that what you'd want? Books of Magic, a relaunch of Amythest, Princess of Gemworld or stuff about angsty but friendly super-natural monsters?
lurkerwithout: (Reading cat)
Yes, I know its long past Sunday. But I was distracted and sleepy and lazy until now...


kimmie66 written and illustrated by Aaron Alexovich, letters by Robert Clark
Burnout written by Rebecca Donner, illustrated by Inaki Miranda, gray tones by Eva de la Cruz, letters by Jared K Fletcher

I missed Ross Campbell's Water Baby. But other reviews have been pretty luke-warm on it, so I've been in no rush...

To start we'll look at kimmie66. A futurist scifi book. Telly Kade is a 23rd century teen. And like most teen's she spends much of her time living in VR worlds. People are supposed to pick one "theme" or Lair and just hang there. For Telly and her friends its a pseudo-WoD setting where they can play at Gothy monster-lite. And Telly is happy with this. She can avoid her creep of a brother and its easier to have friends in the Virtual. Until she gets a suicide note from her friend Kimmie66. A note that leads her from one Lair to another until in search of Kimmie66's "ghost"...

First off, as I mentioned previously, I love Alexovich's art. And the story is another plus. This probably ranks with Confessions of a Blabbermouth and The Re-Gifters as the best of the line. Telly isn't perfect, she's a kid struggling to deal with loss. Good book...

Next we've got Burnout. Teenage Danni and her mom have just moved to a new town. Again. Where Danni's mom gets involved with a local man and the two move in together. Thrusting Danni into sharing a room with her possible future "brother". Brooding hottie Haskell. Finding out that Haskell sneaks out every night, Danni eventually follows him. She learns that he's been engaging in anti-logging activities, spiking trees and the like. Kid wants to be an eco-warrior. And if it'll impress Haskell, so does Danni. The two quickly become a hot & heavy secret couple, while spending their nights on nuisance attacks on the local industry. Of course it all ends in tears and fire...

This one's very teen melodrama. Danni wants to belong to somewhere. Or someone. Or something. Which means she gets drawn into Haskell's drama. I'm still not sure how much I like this one. The art is clean and sharp. And Danni and Haskell seem like teens. Of course teens annoyed me even when I was one. So its a well written book. But if I wasn't trying to check out the entire line as it came out, I don't know how much interest I'd have in the story...
lurkerwithout: (Reading cat)
This week, lets go over the two most recent books from DC's minx line.


Good As Lily
Written by Derek Kirk Kim, Art by Jesse Hamm, Letters by Jared K Fletcher

What the minx line has most reminded me of, are teen movies. With the better ones (Re-Gifters being a Hughes classic or the like. Good As Lily still has that feel to it, but adds a kind of time travel element to it that gives it a more unique feel. After her 18th birthday Grace Kwon is visited by 3 versions of herself. Herself at six, twenty-nine and sixty. Which adds to the difficulty of the standard high school rivalry, the crush on the handsome teacher and the best friend she doesn't notice romantically. Plus of course Lily from the title. Her older sister who died of meningitis at the age of eight. And who still haunts her parents. Kim crafts the story well and Hamm's pencils capture the story perfectly. But without that taste of the different Good As Lily would be pretty good. But with it, it becomes great...



confessions of a blabbermouth
Written by Mike & Louise Carey, Art by Aaron Alexovich, Letters by John J Hill

Mike Carey (who wrote the previous minx book Re-Gifters) co-wrote this one with his 15 year old daughter. Who is already an editorialist for the London Metropolitan Archive and is working on a novel. Alexovich recently won my heart with a fill in issue of Fables, and his cartoony style fits this book perfectly and adds a certain sweetness to it all. confessions of a blabbermouth is about Tasha a teen blogger whose single mom starts dating romance writer and single father Jed Hazel. Which leads to Jed's daughter Chloe being thrust into all aspects of Tasha's life. At school, at home and even on the school yearbook committee. And after Chloe's newspaper editorial is published, where she mercilessly mocks bloggers and seemingly Tasha specifically, Tasha retaliates. In whats a pretty evil manner, especially at the high school level...

Though Tasha at least does end up feeling guilty over her revenge and works to make amends for it. As well as to help Chloe and Jed with their somewhat broken relationship. Chris Sims, of the Invincible Super-Blog, makes a point in his review that Jed, the main villain of the story, doesn't really get punished much and in fact doesn't even try to make ammends for the crap he pulled. Which sadly is what all too often happens in life. Whats important, I think, is Tasha and Chloe's ability to grow beyond it and move forward with their life...

While Good As Lily is probably the best of the line so far, with Re-Gifters and confessions of a blabbermouth Mike Carey is so far the stand-out writer...
lurkerwithout: (Reading cat)
I had been planning on writing up a review of the 3rd minx book, Clubbing. But Chris Sims over at The Invincible Super Blog manages to explain why its so dissatisfying so much better than me. So I'll just yoink his entire review:

"Well, it had to happen sooner or later, but with Clubbing, the Minx line has made its first major misstep. And it’s a sharp drop, too, given that their last offering, Mike Carey and Sonny Liew’s Re-Gifters set the bar so high by being one of the most entertaining graphic novels of the year, and while I didn’t really expect Clubbing to live up, I didn’t expect it to fall quite so flat, either.

The plot is thus: The girl on the cover there is Charlotte Brook. See, she’s from West London, born and raised, and at the goth clubs is where she spends most of her days. Coolin’ out, maxin’ relaxin’ all cool, or stealing some Photoshop from the school, but there’s this one time that she’s up to no good. She starts making trouble in the neighborhood. She gets caught by some cops and her mom gets scared, and says you’re moving with your auntie and uncle in Bel Air.

No, wait. She moves in with her Grandparents in Meadowdale. Sorry, got confused for a second.

Anyway, the problems here are many and varied, starting with the fact that, well, that’s a pretty terrible cover. I’m not sure what the folks at DC thought they were going to accomplish by mixing photography and comic art here, but it doesn’t work, and the perspective is just wrong enough that Charlotte looks to be twelve feet tall and about as natural in her setting as Roger Rabbit. And once you get inside the comic, they just keep stacking up from there.

For one thing, I’m really not sure if Josh Howard’s the right guy to be drawing it. Don’t get me wrong, I actually do like the man’s art, but that’s just the thing: I like it, and I like it because I enjoy pinup-style drawings of angular women in what essentially amounts to fetish gear. Thus, Charlotte changes into a new and revealing outfit in almost every scene, with mini-skirts getting shorter, heels getting higher, and garter belts more visible along the way, which, for a book aimed at young girls, seems awfully exploitative. And then there’s the problem of Charlotte herself: She doesn’t come off as particularly brave, smart, or concerned with anything but herself, leaving me with the problem of a pretty unrelatable protagonist. Admittedly, it’s not designed to relate to me, but I didn’t have much trouble finding something to like about Main Jane and Dixie, either.

And hey, did you know this thing was a murder mystery with a supernatural element to it? No? Yeah, me either, and I’m relatively certain that I pay closer attention to the solicitations than your average joe. There’s one mention of the murder on the back cover copy, and none whatsoever of the supernatural element, which is, y’know, kind of a huge selling point that they might want to draw attention to. Or maybe they skipped it because it’s not introduced until page 108, when the book takes a sharp left turn into the realm of the paranormal for 38 pages. It just would’ve been nice to know, but even with fair warning, it’s still pretty poorly constructed, with a telegraphed ending and no discernable character growth for our alleged heroine.

Oh, and they also misspell Bertie Wooster’s name in the glossary, identifying him as Bernie Wooster. I mean really!"


There are more reasons the art is off-putting, beyond the unneeded goth cheesecake (though Lottie is basically posing in every scene she's in. Even when she's alone. Or reading in the bath (and why is that scene even there?)). And I don't have my copy with me, so I don't know if Josh Howard does all the art related work, but the inks in the book are really heavy...

Oh and the cover since Mr. Sims mentions it:

lurkerwithout: (Reading cat)
Previously DC announced the start of a new imprint of graphic novels, entitled minx. The minx line is meant in part to attract more teen and YA girls into comics. While still telling quality stories. I don't have access to marketing figures to prove or disprove the first. But with two books out, I can take a look at the latter...



The Plain Janes by Cecil Castellucci and Jim Rugg, with lettering by Jared K. Fletcher

The first book deals with Jane who is nearby when a cafe is blown up. Her parents decide to move out to the safe suburbs. So Jane, after dyeing her hair black and deciding to become a new person. So she starts as a freshmen and rejects the popular crowd to try and befriend the "outcast" clique. Who are three girls, Jane the Actress, Jayne the smart kid and Polly Jane the jock. The group eventually gels around committing acts of art vandalism in the local community as P.L.A.I.N. (People Loving Art In Neighborhoods). Making pyramids out of rubble in an abandoned lot, gift wrapping news boxes asking students to sing at school and so on...

The local authorties completely lose their shit over this, enforcing curfews and threatening dire punishments on anyone going along with the P.L.A.I.N. requests. Working as part of P.L.A.I.N. brings the girls closer together and seems to help them grow...

As a story it definately works, though the ending seems somewhat rushed. As well, other than Main Jain, most of the side characters feel somewhat two-dimensional. A good book, that feels like it could have been better served by being in a larger format...



Re-Gifters written by Mike Carey, art by Sonny Liew and Marc Hempel, graytones by Jesse Hamm and lettering by John J. Hill

This book was a no-brainer for me. Carey, Liew and Hempel are the people behind My Faith In Frankie, the greatest love story between a girl, a godling, a dead boy and another girl ever told. Re-Gifters is about Jen Dik Seong or "Dixie". A young Korean girl who uses hapkido to express herself. Dixie is skilled and hopes to win a national championship, but her game is thrown when she begins crushing on fellow student Adam. So much so that she spends her tournament entry money on an expensive birthday gift for him. Which he totally fails to attach any importance to. In fact he re-gifts it to a girl he's crushing on. Who, when she finds out, gives it to her deadbeat brother. He then gives it local teen "thug" Dillenger. Who then gifts it back to Dixie as a thank you for helping him practice his own martial arts...

Again a very good story that feels cramped. Though the characters feel more fully fleshed out than in The Plain Janes. Actually both feel kind of like 80s style teen movies. The Plain Janes could easily be a John Hughes movie, while Re-Gifters is like a mash up of The Karate Kid and Some Kind of Wonderful. Which is far from a bad thing...

Profile

lurkerwithout: (Default)
lurkerwithout

March 2019

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 5th, 2025 02:38 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios