Who Can Save Us Now?
Aug. 31st, 2008 04:22 amSo I've finished this new super-hero themed anthology. And I'm pretty well disapointed by the book. Not only are most of the writers more inclined to other sub-genres, but many of them are just terrible. The opening story "Girl Reporter" is obviously meant to be some kind of parody on the Lois Lane/Superman relationship. Except its about two hateful worthless characters, one who sometimes acts as a super-hero...
In fact the few LIKABLE stories with up-beat endings stand out for their rarity. Editor and contributor Owen King's "The Meerkat" is probably one of the best of the bunch. And then its followed by another pack of poorly written stories until George Singleton's "Man Oh Man - It's Manna Man" which is one of the few to take an interesting concept (a hero who can change what televangelists say on their shows, so that worthy small charities get their flock's donations) and craft a decent story. After that its more interesting idea/poor execution until the final three; Kelly Braffet's "Bad Karma Girl Wins At Bingo", Jennifer Weiner's "League of Justice (Philadelphia Division)" and David Haynes' "The Lives of Ordinary Superheroes"; which manage to end the anthology on an up-note with good stories...
So out of twenty-two short stories, there were FIVE I'd recomend. And two (John McNally's "Remains of the Night" and Sean Doolittle's "Mr. Big Deal") where the concept almost works enough to make up for pointless downer endings. And the remaining fifteen I'd tell anyone to basically pass by...
In fact the few LIKABLE stories with up-beat endings stand out for their rarity. Editor and contributor Owen King's "The Meerkat" is probably one of the best of the bunch. And then its followed by another pack of poorly written stories until George Singleton's "Man Oh Man - It's Manna Man" which is one of the few to take an interesting concept (a hero who can change what televangelists say on their shows, so that worthy small charities get their flock's donations) and craft a decent story. After that its more interesting idea/poor execution until the final three; Kelly Braffet's "Bad Karma Girl Wins At Bingo", Jennifer Weiner's "League of Justice (Philadelphia Division)" and David Haynes' "The Lives of Ordinary Superheroes"; which manage to end the anthology on an up-note with good stories...
So out of twenty-two short stories, there were FIVE I'd recomend. And two (John McNally's "Remains of the Night" and Sean Doolittle's "Mr. Big Deal") where the concept almost works enough to make up for pointless downer endings. And the remaining fifteen I'd tell anyone to basically pass by...